Jobs Summit to be Full of Sound and Fury Signifying Nothing
Posted by Michael A. Kamperman on November 14, 2009
The President has already decided that he is only interested in small and minimalist ideas to create jobs. He does not want to consider programs that will cost a lot of political capital or a lot more of the Treasuries dollars. He and his band of Hoover Liquidationist political and economic advisers are more interested in bringing down the deficit than in putting America back to work. The word is his budget directors are asking his Cabinet Secretaries to prepare two budgets, one for zero growth and one for a 5% across the board reduction in spending for the next fiscal year. They are more interested in making things and selling than to foreigners than to other Americans. He and his liquidationists are crazy if they think the Chinese and the Japanese are going to accept selling a lot less to us and buying a lot more from us. In effect, President Obama is in favor of the American standard of living going down. Therefore, his jobs summit is dead on arrival and will prove to be nothing more than a big show so he can say he tried.
Paul Krugman just said “But these aren’t normal times….so it’s time to try something different.” Yes it is time to try something different. But it is not time to buy into the idea that Washington has already stretched itself to the max and can’t do much more because of the debt and the deficit. President Obama and his economic team are looking for creative ideas to create 10 million jobs on the cheap. There are no magic tricks to turn around the economy. There is only the reality that we will not solve the economic crisis without significant leadership from Washington. President Obama needs to be willing to not only try something different, but something big.
We need to create 10 million new jobs. Assuming each job costs employers an average of $50,000, then it will cost the nation $500 billion a year to add these jobs. The private sector cannot do it right now because the credit markets remain broken and it remains very difficult for many consumers and small businesses to borrow money. Yet one of the ideas to reduce the deficit is to use $200 billion in TARP funds to repay debt and lower the current deficit. Wouldn’t this money be better spent bolstering the community banks that are vital to the small business job creation engine? Yes the New Deal helped during the Great Depression, but the unemployment rate was still over 15% at the end of the 1930′s. It was only the massive fiscal spending to fight World War II that truly ended the Great Depression. A comparable stimulus program today would amount to 8 trillion dollars a year for 4 consecutive years. While that may be over-kill, it emphasizes there is no way to end the economic crisis on the cheap just by tinkering at the edges. Two years ago almost everyone would have agreed that if we entered a deflationary depression there are three things we should avoid doing at all cost. First, the federal government should not cut spending. Next, the federal government should not raise taxes. And finally the federal government should not sanction Zombie banks that only pretend to lend. Amazingly, the Obama administration is hell bent on doing the three things it shouldn’t. What’s worse they want the average American to accept the pain of change.
