Denial, Obfuscation, and Politics as Usual is Killing any Hope of Recovery
Posted by Michael A. Kamperman on August 5, 2009
We are not in an economic recovery, not by a long shot. If estimates are correct the unemployment numbers for July will show somewhere between 300,000 to 450,000 job losses. That would not be a sign of slack hiring but of continued firings. Hiring is a lagging indicator once a recovery takes hold. Continued firing is a clear sign there is no recovery. Confusion about the concept of “net exports” in the GDP data is leading many to misinterpret the state of the economy as being more positive than it really is. U.S. imports and exports peaked in the third quarter of 2008, with exports reaching $1.913 trillion. In the fourth quarter of 2008 total dollar exports fell to $1.706 trillion, followed by a drop to $1.509 trillion in the first quarter of 2009 and a drop to $1.483 trillion in the second quarter of 2009. Yes, the rate of decline is slowing. But the GDP data claims “net exports” added .45% to GDP in the fourth quarter of 2008, added 2.64% positive growth in the first quarter of 2009, and finally added 1.38% to positive GDP growth in the second quarter of 2009. Our actual exports have fallen by over 20% in the last three quarters and yet our GDP calculation claims “net exports” have added 4.5% to our economic growth. The firing data offers a clearer picture of the true state of the economy. Firing is not a lagging or leading indicator, it is a current indicator. If the July unemployment report estimates are accurate, then the economy was still falling and not in a state of recovery in the month of July. Yet July is part of the third quarter when the average forecast of economists is calling for positive GDP growth.
Many look to China as a source of economic strength and positioned to lead a global economic recovery. The latest data out of South Korea says otherwise. According to Bloomberg news, “exports to China, South Korea’s biggest overseas market, fell 15.7 percent from a year earlier in the first 20 days of July. Exports to the U.S. slid 26.5 percent in the period while shipments to Japan fell 32.6 percent, today’s report showed.” China claims a 7.9% second quarter growth rate and yet, just like the U.S. and Japan whose economies are in an acknowledged deep slump, China is importing much less than it did last year.
The economic strategy being employed by the White House is being driven more by the political advisers than the economic advisers. Today the President and his Administration began making a concerted effort to convince Americans the economy is doing better than expected, and the stimulus plan is working as intended. Considering the stimulus plan was supposed to keep unemployment around 8% in 2009 and it will soon reach 10%, just what is the objective of this plan of denial and obfuscation? The objective is to paint the picture the President has a solid plan for the economy. No, he doesn’t. What the President needs to do is say the economy is in much worse shape than expected and that is unacceptable. He should say the stimulus plan, while helpful, is proving to be not nearly effective enough in stopping the economy from declining. He should say he is willing to stake his Presidency on restoring jobs in America and will do whatever it takes to make that happen. President Obama, I will tell you what your political advisers should have already told you, your Presidency is already staked to the unemployment rate.
